The Left’s Latest Hobby: Love for Confining People for Their ‘Own Good’

Apr 29, 2025 | The Guardian

Exploring the Left's Perspective on Confinement as a Protective Measure
Original Article | Author: Jordyn Jensen
In the US, a resurgence of psychiatric institutionalization is occurring under the guise of modern mental health care. From expanding involuntary commitment policies in New York to "wellness farms" proposed by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., these initiatives aim to increase state control over marginalized populations, including disabled, unhoused, racialized, and LGBTQIA+ communities. While marketed as compassionate care, these policies emphasize surveillance and detention, echoing historical practices of confinement. They undermine community-based solutions, erode individual autonomy, and perpetuate systems of control, masking their punitive nature as therapeutic interventions.

Here’s What They Meant to Say

Pretending Forcing People Into Institutions Is Progressive

Ah, the left and their shiny new obsession – psychiatric imprisonment! Just when you think their love for big government couldn’t get any bigger, they surprise you again. Forget old-school asylums, we have ‘wellness farms’ and expanded involuntary commitment policies. Under the guise of compassion, they’re all about bringing back the ‘good ole days’ of institutionalization, just with a modern twist.

Hypocrisy on Display Across the States

Look at Kathy Hochul in New York, fervently pushing for involuntary commitment like it’s an iPhone launch. And let’s not overlook our friend Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who dreamt up ‘wellness farms’ with his Make America Healthy Again initiative. A whole new level of condescension masquerading as care! These democrat-driven initiatives might vary in their vocabulary, but they’ve got one core mission: expanding state power to keep tabs on, detain, and ‘treat’ those pesky marginalized groups.

It’s Not Care, It’s Control

Underneath the fluff of ‘treatment’ and ‘support’ lies the same old authoritarian instincts. Disabled, unhoused, minority, and LGBTQIA+ communities have seen through this charade. Institutionalization portrayed as care merely continues the cycle of erasing true community-based solutions and trampling individual autonomy. But of course, nothing screams progress quite like coercion and control.

Wrap-Up: The Left’s Less-Than-Caring ‘Care’

In the self-congratulatory world of leftist policymaking, incarceration, by any other name, is still that – incarceration. This is the beauty of progressive politics, folks: when all else fails, just slap a new label on a bad idea and call it innovation. Their solutions? Why not try meaningful community support instead? But I guess that doesn’t come with the same headlines.

Conclusion

And there you have it: the left’s latest hobby-trickling their way into control, one ‘treatment’ at a time. You’ve got to hand it to them; if nothing else, they are consistent in their inconsistency.

Radical Left Sources


Welcome to RadicalLeft.net, where we take the most absurd, biased left-wing narratives and rewrite them with a healthy dose of reality, sarcasm, and unapologetic conservative wit. We don’t just challenge the mainstream media—we mock it, exposing its hypocrisy, double standards, and straight-up nonsense. If you’re tired of the usual woke drivel and want a brutally honest, right-wing take on today’s biggest stories, you’re in the right place. No safe spaces here—just facts, humor, and a whole lot of common sense.